Svend’s Beer Rating System

I wanted to write a bit about my beer rating system, as I’ve now been using it for a while without any explanation, and it’s not necessarily obvious to anyone else what the different numbers mean.

The system is not very different from the “official” Camra rating system, but in case you’re not familiar with that one either, here’s a full description of how my system works.

Rated 1-5. The ratings go from 1 to 5. I don’t give any half marks. If a beer seems to be “on the border” between two scores, I’ll just have to make that more of an effort to decide which one it really belongs to.

1 – This score is reserved for undrinkable beers. I’ve not given this more than once or twice so far, and it’s normally a case of a poor beer in a poor condition.

2 – Two is a score for beers I don’t like, but I can finish them. They are beers that I would gladly never drink again. It might happen, though, that I’ve given a beer 2, and then come across it at a later date where it fares better, simply because it’s been cared for better.

3 – Three is by far the most common score. This is probably also the widest. It covers beers that I like, but that don’t blow my socks off. Some might just be nice, inoffensive beers. Maybe a cold, crisp lager on a warm day by the sea. Others might be interesting beers with lots of flavour and ambition, but don’t quite work well enough to make a 4.

4 – On a good day you might have a couple of fours. Especially at a beer festival or an excellent pub where the beers have been expertly cared for, and served in pristine condition.

5 – Fives are rare. They should be. If they weren’t the system wouldn’t be very useful, as it wouldn’t be able to single out those beers that go the extra mile, past decent, through lovely and all the way to amazing.

47 thoughts on “Svend’s Beer Rating System

  1. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2014 10 | shotgundentist

  2. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2014 09 | shotgundentist

  3. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2014 08 | shotgundentist

  4. Pingback: Svend’s Cider Blog 2014 | shotgundentist

  5. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2014 07 | shotgundentist

  6. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2014 06 | shotgundentist

  7. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2014 05 | shotgundentist

  8. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2014 04 | shotgundentist

  9. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2014 03 | shotgundentist

  10. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2014 02 | shotgundentist

  11. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2014 11 | shotgundentist

  12. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2014 11 | shotgundentist

  13. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2014 12 | shotgundentist

  14. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2015 01 | shotgundentist

  15. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2015 02 | shotgundentist

  16. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2015 03 | shotgundentist

  17. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2015 04 | shotgundentist

  18. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2015 05 01 | shotgundentist

  19. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2015 06 | shotgundentist

  20. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2015 07 | shotgundentist

  21. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2015 08 | shotgundentist

  22. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2015 09 | shotgundentist

  23. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2015 10 | shotgundentist

  24. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2015 11 | shotgundentist

  25. Pingback: shotgundentist

  26. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2016 01 | shotgundentist

  27. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2016 02 | shotgundentist

  28. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2016 03 | shotgundentist

  29. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2016 04 | shotgundentist

  30. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2016 05 | shotgundentist

  31. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2016 06 | shotgundentist

  32. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2016 07 | shotgundentist

  33. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2016 08 | shotgundentist

  34. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2016 09 | shotgundentist

  35. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2016 10 | shotgundentist

  36. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2016 11 | shotgundentist

  37. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2016 12 | shotgundentist

  38. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2017 01 | shotgundentist

  39. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2017 02 | shotgundentist

  40. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2017 03 | shotgundentist

  41. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2017 04 | shotgundentist

  42. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2017 05 | shotgundentist

  43. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2017 06 | shotgundentist

  44. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2017 07 | shotgundentist

  45. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2017 08 | shotgundentist

  46. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2017 09 | shotgundentist

  47. Pingback: Svend’s Beer Log 2017 10 | shotgundentist

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.